Baking dishes such as popular casserole pans by Pyrex are versatile substitutions for a jelly roll pan. You can go classic with fudge brownies and snickerdoodle bars, or dazzle taste buds with blueberry lattice bars and pistachio-cherry smore bars. This is another great alternative for making jelly roll pans. When you use a casserole pan it is highly recommended to fill up the pan with less, especially if you are making a cake. The most popular sizes used in recipes and cakes is 10 by 15 inches, but you will find larger sizes as well. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. How To Substitute Pans: The following table will help determine substitutions of pans and For example, you cannot cook the jelly roll on a cookie sheet. Many manufacturers these days refer to just about every other rimmed baking sheet as jelly roll pans even the half sheet pans, which usually measure 13 by 18 inches. But if you dont mind anything less than perfect, then you should be fine with a half sheet pan as it yields extremely like-for-like results. Get all the knowledge and expertise of Baking 911 in an all new package! Samantha is a mother of two kids, so is well-versed in the best toys for kids and household goods. But theres no need to be intimidated by its looks the technique is easily achievable even by a novice baker, as long as you have the right tools. 1/2 Read More, INGREDIENTS Making things worse is the fact that some manufacturers apply the same label to all pan sizes and variants probably make for easier packaging none of which helps our case. No, a jelly roll pan is not the same as a cookie sheet. The cookie sheets are without edges since their design is for cookies to be placed all over the surface. In most cases, jelly roll pans and cookie sheets can be used interchangeably. Don't like an ingredient in this nacho recipe? You can do all of the things that a jelly roll pan can do, except, of course, youll be cooking on a smaller scale. Can You Line Brownie Pan with Parchment Paper. Stir and serve. It is a high-quality aluminum that is rust-resistant and super versatile! With the advancement of modern accessories, it is now possible to get an alternative to jelly roll pans. 5 Essentials You Did Not Know Your Bedroom Needs, Best Pellet Smoker of 2023 Review & Buyers Guide, Garmin InReach Mini Review Ultra-Compact Satellite Tech For Your Adventure, Sheet pan (regular sized): 10 1/2 wide by 15 1/2 long by 1 depth can hold 10 cups, Sheet pan (large-sized): 12 1/2 wide by 17 1/2 long by 1 deep can hold 12 cups. Some of our partners may process your data as a part of their legitimate business interest without asking for consent. Cream together butter, sugars and vanilla extract in a large bowl. However, the primary difference that exists between the two is with respect to the edges. Stir and serve. Click below to start your order online or download the Meals 2GO app for easyordering. Youll see many cookware brands using the words cookie sheet and baking pan interchangeably but they are actually two different things. Roll up the cake and sprinkle with powdered sugar. Remove lids and place pans on baking sheets. Add eggs, one at a time, It is a rust-proof pan. I have been working as a professional ceramic artist for over 25 years. The jelly roll pan has extremely unique dimensions that are ideal for giving your cake the unique sponge or sheet-like structure to retain shape after filling and rolling. WebNorpro Stainless Steel 15 x 10 Inch Jelly Roll Pan Norpro 2 $30.85 When purchased online Sold and shipped by BigKitchen a Target Plus partner Trudeau 10x15" Cookie Sheet Trudeau 2 $9.99 When purchased online Wilton 9"x13" Nonstick Ultra Bake Professional Baking Pan with Cover Wilton 239 $13.99 When purchased online INGREDIENTS To solve this problem you need to lengthen the baking time and lower the temperature of the oven slightly. Measure Dimensions: To determine the pans dimensions always measure inside edge to inside edge of the pan so that you do not include the thickness of the pan in your measurement. But if you have a traditional jelly roll pan, use the 15X10 pan that the original recipe recommends. I didnt want a thin cake. A jelly roll (or the Swiss roll), for instance, can and should only be tried on a jelly roll pan. Let us find out some jelly roll pan substitutes. In the case of the half sheet pan with its wider area, your batter will be spread too thin for you to make any adjustments to the filling. The flat cake is then rolled into the traditional shape of a jelly roll. It is designed to bake sheet cakes or thin sponges that are thick enough to fill with jelly or crme and roll into a cylindrical shape. WebHowever, most people now use jelly roll pans for general baking and roasting tasks rather than baking jelly rolls, so you'll find them in a wider range of sizes. We are glad to have provided you with this list of the best substitutes for jelly roll pans. It is one of the non-stick products that you can use for baking purposes. The raised sides also provide the containment needed for It will help us use the products in the best possible manner. Bring to a boil; remove from heat. Because of this, you will have to adjust the cooking time accordingly make sure to keep checking in every 5 to 10 minutes earlier than normal if youre using a jelly roll pan and check to see how theyre baking. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Substitute Cooking 2023 - All Right Reserved. You can do all of the things that a jelly roll pan can do, except, of course, youll be cooking on a smaller scale. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Too little batter will result in a cake thats too thin and will likely break apart if you attempt to roll it. Refrigerate leftovers promptly. Remove lid and place pan on baking sheet. Preheat oven to 400 degrees F. Grease a 10 x 15-inch jelly roll pan and set aside. In a large bowl, stir together the flour, 1/2 cup sugar, and salt. Luckily, Taste of Homes Test Kitchen experts have the answer: perfectly sliced dessert bars. Once completely cooked and cooled the filling is spread over the cake. You must also have a clear conception of what the use of a jelly pan is. It can be a small variant of the half sheet pan. Breaking Bread: Top 5 Bread Flour Substitutes. We are no longer supporting IE (Internet Explorer), Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Peanut Butter Bars, Do not Sell or Share My Personal Information. Every now and then youll find recipes referring to jelly roll pans if you want to cook them for perfection. Carefully remove the foil and towel, starting from the narrow end. As the name of the pan suggests, it measures 913. A full sheet pan measures 26 by 18 inches and features 1-inch sides. Baking recipes that specifically ask for a jelly roll pan, including the jelly roll, cannot be easily adapted to another pan. Want to cook just like our Test Kitchen? Mostbaking panscan fill in nicely for jelly roll pans, just make sure they have 1-inch edges otherwise the cake wont hold its shape. In most cases, jelly roll pans and cookie sheets can be used interchangeably. Make sure that you use it for something that is more suitable, since if you bake a thin cake it may crack and burn. When searching for a jelly or swiss roll pan substitute we have a great eco-friendly choice. The most popular sizes used in recipes and cakes is 10 by 15 inches, but you will find larger sizes as well. (Especially when one of these gorgeous cakes are on the table!) The direct me to a website Here are some of the best substitutes for a jelly roll pan. Rather than a standard kitchen knife Taste of Homes Test Kitchen turns to a bench scraperto cut dessert bars. Substitutes for jelly roll pan include a half sheet pan, cookie sheet, full sheet pan, quarter sheet, Doughmaker aluminum baking pan, casserole pan, Nordic ware aluminum nonstick pan, and 913 pans. As an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases made through links in this post. (How to Measure Volume). They are very famous. 2 large pink or red grapefruits, preferably organic Since there is a wide range of options for cake pans, it may be a bit tricky to find the best one so youll get perfect results. The Half sheet pan is a great option if you dont have many guests to feed. Its nonstick surface easily releases your treats and makes clean-up easier than ever. Let rest for 5 minutes, then serve. Spray your baking sheet well with baking spray or butter and flour. It is another good substitute for the jelly roll pan. With these alternatives and substitutes, you can easily bake your favorite cakes and cookies at home. You can adjust the quantity of the materials while using the pan. Preheat oven to 375F. ! You know those durable aluminum foil baking sheets with sides that are used in bake sales? WebDescription. This smaller pan measures 13 by 9 inches. If youre unfamiliar, a bench scraper is a super-tool made of thin metal that can be used to divide doughs, chop veg, cut pasta and scrape bits and pieces off your counters and pans. Taste of Home is America's #1 cooking magazine. Another great substitute for a jelly roll pan is a casserole pan. Turn the pan to its shorter side and make one cut down the middle, 4 -inches from the edge. You can also use it as an alternative to jelly roll pans. HEAT INGREDIENTS. Since most of the recipes tell you that you have to fill up the jolly pan almost an inch, that means that a wider half sheet pan will spread your mixture and make it too thin. Wilton Perfect Results Premium Nonstick 15-Inch x 10-Inch Jelly Roll Pan. Its rust-resistant and the wire grid features 3/8-inch holes. Both the rack and baking sheet are safe in the oven up to 575 degrees. While Ultra Cuisine recommends hand-washing the jelly roll pan, the rack is dishwasher-safe. Dimensions: 16.1 x 11.2 x 1.3 inches | Material: Aluminum (Sheet Pan) & Stainless Steel (Rack) | Weight: 2.44 lbs Preheat oven to 400F. Beat in water and vanilla at slow speed. However, notethat the surface is non-stick which is perfect for baking. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. From the edge, measure out, Repeat on the other side of the middle cut. Spread dough in pan and bake 25 to 30 minutes. You can also use it for baking other things. Casserole pan 6. Bake for 35 minutes until internal temperature reaches 165F. Pour 8 oz of Wegmans Culinary Chicken Stock over turkey (may use water or chicken broth as a substitute). Typically, jelly roll pans are made from aluminum or aluminized steel. Continue with Recommended Cookies. vegetables. Check the list and take your pick. Home Best Substitutes for Jelly Roll Pan. Youll notice that cookie sheets and jelly roll pans look extremely similar and share the same dimensions; however, there is one very major difference between the two. This will enable you to get better baking products. A jelly roll pan has a 1-inch lip around the edges that make it easier to cook jelly rolls. Set aside. The only way we see a full sheet pan being used in a home environment is as an organizing bin for the pantry. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. However, you need the right size or your cake layers will come out to be very thin and may even burn to a crisp. However, a jelly roll pan is used to do many of the same tasks as a cookie sheet without a hitch. Beat together melted butter and brown sugar over medium speed with an electric mixer. Baking recipes that specifically ask for a jelly roll pan, including the jelly roll, cannot be easily adapted to another pan. This surface is ideal for making foods like cookies and similar other ones. Slow Cooker. Go for it! Measure to the middle of the full-sized piece and cut through the columns. On the long side of the pan, make a mark and cut down every 2 1/10-inches, so you have 6 columns. In the case of cookie sheets, they have one or two sides bent for easier handling. I dont know the URL. For a 139 pan: Start on the shorter side facing toward you. You can use it for many types of baking. The only issue is that in order to make a jelly roll (a.k.a. At some point you may choose to purchase your own jelly roll pan. We are no longer supporting IE (Internet Explorer) as we strive to provide site experiences for browsers that support new web standards and security practices. When it comes to baking we add up to our game equipment that is suitable for almost everything. Is There a Difference Between Cookie Sheets and Jelly Roll Pans? They vary in size and usage. Use a fork to spread jelly over the cake. 4ComiPa!
, 8 Amazing Types of Italian Cookies You Need To Know, 6 Different Types of Cream Cheese Pie and How to Cook Them, Gorgeous Philly Cheesesteak Recipe in 2021, Everything about Smoked Pulled Pork in 2021, MAC AND CHEESE WITH VELVEETA AND EVAPORATED MILK RECIPES, HOW LONG DO COOKED BLACK BEANS LAST IN FRIDGE RECIPES, CREAM CHEESE AND STRAWBERRY DESSERT RECIPES, 2 cups toll house semisweet chocolate morsels. Turn the pan longways. $63.69. Its also a good pan for toaster cooking, drying out ingredients in the refrigerator, organizing, and freezing batches of cookies before placing them in plastic freezer bags. Have you ever tried brushing the cake layers with Big hole in swirled bread loaf with filling. Most recipes for jelly roll ask you to fill the jelly roll pan with batter. I keep getting the SAME ANSWERS. Pour it into the pan, spreading to all corners. You must know that a full sheet pan measures about 26 by 18 inches. Once 15 minutes have passed, immediately remove the cake from the pans sides and flip it upside down onto a towel. Jelly Roll Pan Substitutes 1. Cut three long rows into your bars (thats three 3-inch rows). Carefully remove the foil and towel, starting from the narrow end. Preheat oven to 350F; remove Chicken Wings, Tenders or Bites from package. Remove dipping sauce from the tray. We and our partners use cookies to Store and/or access information on a device. Preheat oven to 400F. What Is the Difference Between Bundt Cake Pan and Tube Pan? When we compare the two items the jelly roll pan is smaller than the baking sheet. Approximate Pan Dimensions (centimeters) (cm). The construction allows air to properly flow around the cookies as they properly bake. The most popular sizes used in recipes and cakes Cream together butter, sugars and vanilla extract in a large bowl. Plus, a scraper gives you control to use an up/down cutting motion, rather than the dragging of a knife, meaning your edges wont be full of crumbs and loose chunks. This fluffy cake is rolled around an extraordinary silky frosting, earning it a place of honor on any menu. Sides heat while ham is resting. The recipe for these tangy lemon bars comes from my cousin Bernice, a farmer's wife famous for cooking up feasts. Cut in 1 cup of margarine until mixture resembles coarse crumbs. OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Jelly Roll 10 x 15 Inch, Chicago Metallic Commercial II Traditional Uncoated True Jelly Roll Pan, 15-Inch by10-Inch, Jelly Roll Pan 15x10 - HONGBAKE Commercial Cookie Sheets for Baking with Diamond Texture Surface, 57% Thicker Carbon Steel Baking Sheet for Oven, Nonstick Cooking Tray, Nonstick Jelly Roll Baking Sheet Pan by Ultra Cuisine Food-Safe, Warp & Scratch Resistant Texture for Airflow, & Carbon Steel Design Durable for Professional Quality Roasting, Size 10 x 15 inch, Circulon Nonstick Bakeware, Nonstick Cookie Sheet / Baking Sheet - 10" x 15", Gray, Rachael Ray Nonstick Bakeware with Grips, Nonstick Cookie Sheet / Baking Sheet - 10 Inch x 15 Inch, Gray with Orange Grips, casaWare 15 x 10 x 1-Inch Ultimate Series Commercial Weight Ceramic Non-Stick Coating Cookie/Jelly Roll Pan (Blue Granite), casaWare 2pc Ultimate Commercial Weight 15 x 10 x 1-Inch Cookie Sheet Set (Silver Granite), DecorRack Non-Stick Baking Sheet, 15 x 10 Inch Jelly Roll Pan and Cookie Baking Tray, Heavy Duty Bakeware For Oven (Pack of 1). Use cookie sheets to bake all kinds of different baking goods, but keep in mind what type you choose. Add eggs, one at a time, to butter mixture, beating well after each addition. Thats why make sure to use proper amounts and sizes. WebLightly grease a 10x15-inch jellyroll pan. Excluded from coupons. Here is Whats Cooking Americas recipe and directions for making Lamingtons: Lamington Cake History and Recipe, What do u mean by 3 cup or 4 cup baking dish or pan. All products we review and the information we provide are fully researched. Typically it is said that when you make a jelly roll pan to fill up the pan with batter under the top, but that does not always work. The size of a half sheet cake pan is approximately 13W x 18W X 1H. Roll up the cake and wrap it in plastic wrap. Substitutes for jelly roll pan include a half sheet pan, cookie sheet, full sheet pan, quarter sheet, Doughmaker aluminum baking pan, Start on the shorter side facing toward you. Again, allow your bars to cool completely, then remove them from the pan using the parchment paper lining. Heat the oven to 380F. Aluminum baking pan for doughmaker 5. (new Image()).src = 'https://capi.connatix.com/tr/si?token=bd5526af-9c84-429a-baca-e1c4e1072ef9&cid=877050e7-52c9-4c33-a20b-d8301a08f96d'; cnxps.cmd.push(function () { cnxps({ playerId: "bd5526af-9c84-429a-baca-e1c4e1072ef9" }).render("7917806a0d7f4109a1cb2a4492c81a1a"); }); Once the pan has been prepped, fill it with your dessert bar batter and bake as directed. Even heating for exceptional baking performance. Quarter Sheet 3. Remove wrap, roast at 450F for about 12 min or until internal temperature reaches 145F. For your first layer, youll want the parchment paper to reach up the sides of the pan, so cut the paper a little long. She enjoys writing, painting, teaching, and research. As a native of New Orleans, cooking is second nature to me. A jelly roll pan is a variation of the rectangular sheet pan with 1 inch deep sides, you could argue that it is the smaller variant of a half-sheet pan. Another good quality is that this type of pan provides enough airflow, which means your baking goods will turn out with a nice browning crunch. After viewing product detail pages, look here to find an easy way to navigate back to pages you are interested in. In the case of cookie sheets, they have one or two sides bent for easier handling. Now youll have 21 2 x. To substitute a pan that is deeper than the pan in the recipe, increase the baking time by 1/4. Your email address will not be published. I think I was cooking even before I learned to walk! *For a pan cookie (15x10 inch jelly-roll pan): Grease pan, prepare dough as indicated above, spread into pan and bake 17-19 minutes. WebThe two most dominant non-commercial jelly roll pans have the following dimensions; Sheet pan (regular sized): 10 1/2 wide by 15 1/2 long by 1 depth can hold 10 cups Sheet pan Many manufacturers these days refer to just about every other rimmed baking sheet as jelly roll pans even the half sheet pans, which usually measure 13 by 18 inches. Warming times may vary depending on your equipment. Prevent your dessert bars from sticking to their pan by properly preparing and greasing the pan. Keep reading to learn our Test Kitchens preferred cutting methods and more must-have baking tips. It might not seem the most exciting, but clean-cut bars lookprofessional and willensure every slice is as even as the next. First, line your baking pan with two layers of parchment paper. Remove garnish (kale & oranges) and spread turkey slices evenly on platter. It also provides high air flow that will help in a better baking process. Because of this, you will have to adjust the cooking time accordingly make sure to keep checking in every 5 to 10 minutes earlier than normal if youre using a jelly roll pan and check to see how theyre baking. Check out all of our experts favorite kitchen tools here. We want you to be armed with the best knowledge to enable you to make informed buying decisions and most importantly to have fun cooking! Measure to the middle point and cut away from you. Its a flat sheet pan that has a 1-inch rim along the edges of the pan. The pans are named after a dish that often cant be perfected without them: the jelly roll (or Swiss roll cake). Share your findings with us in the comments below. Most recipes for jelly roll ask you to fill the jelly roll pan with batter. Samantha has an encyclopedic knowledge of cooking food, and is always looking for chances to expand on that. Casserole pan is another good replacement for jelly roll pan. A jelly roll (or the Swiss roll), for instance, can and should only be tried on a jelly roll pan. WebCan I substitute a jelly roll pan? You can conveniently use it for various other purposes. A pan that is too deep will end in a cake that is too thick to be rolled. Dry the cake on cooling air for about 30 minutes. Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. For example, you cannot cook the jelly roll on a cookie sheet. Of course, you can use a 9 x13 pan instead of a jelly roll pan. Now add in granulated sugar. In a large bowl, whisk together sugar, flour, baking soda and salt. Instead, Full Sheet pans are used by caterers and restaurants. Want to add something else? Roll up the cake and wrap it in plastic wrap. You can use them for tasks like roasting veggies, oven fries, baking cookies, chicken, fish, and nuts the works. However, note that you have to adjust the original recipe based on the quantity. A jelly roll pan is larger than a standard 13x9 pan so there is more room for nacho-y goodness. Your email address will not be published. FRIENDS20 (20% OFF) at checkout Quantity + product details. To substitute a pan that is shallower than the pan in the recipe, reduce the baking time by 1/4. As an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases made through links on this site. Made from heavy-weight carbon steel for superior heat conduction and even baking, this strong and durable pan features a rolled rim to prevent warping, and a nonstick coating for easy release and cleanup. Copyright 2022 NRR. You can make Jelly rolls, but you should keep in mind that the recipe may be difficult to adapt. It is mostly used in commercial places and restaurants. We recommend our users to update the browser. If you dont have a jelly roll pan, you can also use a full sheet pan. This type of sheet measures around 26 by 18 inches and has 1-inch sides. It may be bigger, so you have to adjust it according to your oven. These types of sheets are commonly used in restaurants. 4. Quarter sheet Find the halfway point between the edge and the middle cut, and cut all the way down. Preheat conventional oven to 350F. Youll end up with 12 2 1/104 -inch rectangles. Bake for 60 minutes until internal temperature reaches 165F. The first thing that comes to mind if you dont have a jelly roll pan is to use a half sheet pan. HOW TO WARM HAM & SIDES In stock for standard shipping. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. 4 ounces bittersweet chocolate, chopped They are usually marketed as cookie sheets but they typically have raised sides and the 1 depth thats needed for baking jelly rolls. There are many different baking pans and a long list of different desserts and baking goods that come to your mind when its time for cooking. Now that we know what a jelly roll pan is, but still dont have it at home, here are replacements that can be used. The Baking Pan Substitutions Chart shows the sizes and volume of some of the common bakeware pans. Making things worse is the fact that some manufacturers apply the same label to all pan sizes and variants probably make for easier packaging none of which helps our case. **IMPORTANT NOTE: Microwave Instructions Only. Jelly roll pans come with raised edges. One weekend I decided to make my own jelly roll for our familys weekend brunch but soon learned I needed a specialized jelly roll pan. Cool on baking sheets 2 minutes, then transfer to wire racks. When it comes to equipping your kitchen, baking sheets are more versatile. The following table will help determine substitutions of pans and dishes of similar approximate size if you do not have the specific sized baking pan, dish, or mold called for in a recipe. The classic Jelly Roll cake is an impressive dish that will take center stage on any dessert table. This results in a cake that is 1 in height and sturdy enough to hold lots of filling. [emailprotected]. This website is owned and operated by Ashley Robinson. You can also find some differences with respect to the look of the pans. Bake for 20 minutes in the preheated oven. NOTE: If you choose to reheat sides in a microwave, move product into your own microwave-safe containers. This matters a lot because you need to adjust the quantity you add for baking. A jelly roll pan is always a tempting option for many baking goods and desserts. Use a liquid measuring cup to pour water into the pan until it reaches the top. What is a shallow baking pan: the main information, How to season a ceramic pan: tips for any hostess, Shine bright: all you need to know about how to season a copper pan, How to make a pan non stick again. Heating time may vary. OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Jelly Roll 10 x 15 Inch 4.8 out of 5 stars2,854 $21.99$21.99$25.99$25.99 FREE delivery Sun, Apr 23 on $25 of items shipped by Amazon Or fastest delivery Thu, Apr 20 Turn slow cooker to high heat for 1 hour, stirring occasionally, until internal temperature reaches 165F. To substitute with glass pans, reduce the baking temperature by 25 degrees. Additionally, we participates in various other affiliate programs, and we sometimes get a commission through purchases made through our links. This is absent in the case of cookie sheets. Then fill the pot quarter way up with water, place it on the stove, cover with lid and start on low heat for 5 minutes. The half sheet cake pan can be an ideal substitute. It is found in most of the cases that because of the large size of the pan, it cannot fit well in home ovens. However, a jelly roll pan is used to do many of the same tasks as a cookie sheet without a hitch. Now that your dessert bars are perfectly cut, pack them back up in their pan or on a decorative platter and get ready to impress your friends and family. With this pan, you can get a brown finish on the baking products. if pan is filled to its rim. Im a food blogger and a part time chef in Food & Drink Junction, Denver. Here are some of our absolute favorite dessert bar recipes for inspiration. Share your findings with us in the comments below. Freeze for 3 hours or until firm. A full sheet pan measures 26 by 18 inches and features 1-inch sides. Our editors and experts handpick every product we feature. If you want to make a good and tasty cake, you must prefer using this pan. Whether its for a holiday dinner, potluck or bake sale, dessert bars are a crowd-pleasing dessert option for nearly every occasion. However, they are almost similar to each other. Bake for 15-20 minutes until internal temperature reaches 165F. This cookie sheet by G & S Metal is only 0.7 in depth. Single Stage Snow Blower VS Two Stage Which Snow Blower is best for you? These pans are available in aluminum and steel materials. to log in. that give all of the different pans but NOT THE 11 x 17 one I need for the recipe Im making. These cookies do not store any personal information. So there you have it, most baking pans can serve the same purpose as a jelly roll pan as long as they have a 1-inch side. So there you have it, most baking pans can serve the same purpose as a jelly roll pan as long as they have a 1-inch side. The two most dominant non-commercial jelly roll pans have the following dimensions; This brings us to an important question: is there a substitute for a jelly roll pan? Hi, my name is Ashley Robinson. However, you cannot substitute them if you are baking a finicky dish that calls for the specific qualities of a jelly roll pan. A casserole dish makes a good jelly roll pan substitute. Pro Tip: You can use an ice cream filling instead of jam. This Farberware cookie pan is a must-have for every baking enthusiast. The classic Jelly Roll cake is an impressive dish that will take center stage on any dessert table. 3 Bundt Pan Substitutes + How to Make DIY Bundt Pan, 5 Tart Pan Substitutes (that work just as good). 7. Pour the hot butter mixture over the flour mixture. Hello, I am Saurabh and I love cooking. If you use the real deal, on the other hand, you can bet that the jelly roll will come out looking (and tasting) perfect without any signs of cracking, burning, or crumbling.